Pastor and Audio Therapist Rosemarie Muth from Pastoral Care for Hard of Hearing People, Germany, and her partner, have written an eye opening article on the subject of the use of Bluetooth technology in assistive listening and compared it to the classic hearing / induction loop. Please see below for more details.
Is it still worth installing induction loops or will we have Bluetooth public hearing systems for the hearing impaired in the future?
Pastor and Audio Therapist,
Pastoral Care for Hard of Hearing People, Protestant Church of Württemberg, Germany
and Norbert Muth
For more information visit:
To say it in advance: The classic induction loop is still the clear choice. And that will probably remain the case for the next 10-20 years.
In January 2020, after 7 years of planning and discussion at the instigation of EHIMA (European Hearing Instrument Manufacturers Association), an extension to the Bluetooth Low Energy standard was finally decided: Bluetooth Low Energy Audio
Previous versions were either not able to transmit audio at all, or if so, only with expensive hearing aids and usually only with proprietary technology from Apple compatible only with newer iPhones. So far, however, only a limited number of devices (max. 2 hearing aids in parallel) can be connected. As a public assistive listening system it is therefore not suitable. That has changed with the new Bluetooth Low Energy Audio standard, at least in theory. Only the future will show whether this can be achieved in practice. It depends on very different factors, such as the acceptance of the hard of hearing people, the usability and, last but not least, whether it can succeed in ensuring a stable transmission network.
One thing is certain, Bluetooth Low Energy Audio will appear in the first hearing aids in 1-2 years at the earliest. So far, it has not been installed in any hearing aid. It will also not be possible to issue a software upgrade for already existing hearing aids, as the physical hardware would not be compatible. Some hearing aid manufacturers now have to redesign, reprogram, produce and, above all, re-approve their hearing aid chips worldwide. That alone will consume time and money. Therefore, it is very likely that the most expensive hearing aids will be equipped first, then the medium-priced hearing aids, and only after a considerable delay will the basic devices also be equipped with Bluetooth Low Energy Audio functionality, as we have seen with other innovations in hearing aids.
So, it will take at least several years, until (perhaps) most new hearing aids will have Bluetooth Low Energy Audio. However, not all people will have hearing aids with this technology by then. Hearing aids in Germany usually have to be worn for 6 years. Most people who have to make a co-payment however, wear their devices significantly longer. This means that we can expect comprehensive coverage with Bluetooth Low Energy Audio at the earliest 10 years after the sale of the last hearing aids without Bluetooth Low Energy Audio. These periods are mostly underestimated, as not all people are supplied with high-end devices or have the money for new ones. Especially people aged 80 and over often no longer buy new hearing aids “because it doesn’t pay off for me”.
Induction loops will not “die” that quickly. They are still the most reliable, cost-effective and low-maintenance hearing system available to us. They are also the only public assistive listening technology that are barrier-free and will remain so, at least for the next 2-3 generations of hearing impaired people! This is why the International Hearing Access Committee (IHAC) assumes a time window of at least 10-15 years or even more. (https://www.ampetronic.com/2019/08/hearing-loops-and-telecoils-could-they-be-replaced-soon/)
After that, induction loops and Bluetooth Low Energy Audio (or other successor standards) could coexist, and maybe it will stay that way for a very, very long time. It is not yet clear whether this will not even become the norm. We recently spoke to the Technical development manager of a hearing aid company. He strongly believes that for hearing aids which only have Bluetooth Low Energy Audio (instead of telecoil), there will be additional external devices for inductive reception.
Perhaps inductive hearing aids will eventually be replaced by this or another technology, but one thing is certain, Bluetooth Low Energy Audio will not be an option for the next generation of hearing-impaired people. Most of them will not be able to use it and will therefore be dependent on a different solution. Also, as a rule, the inductive hearing system (installed above ground) continues to be the basic technology for primary care. The telecoil will not disappear, despite gloomy predictions, because it will remain necessary for those countries, where a comprehensive supply of the latest smartphones is not economically viable.
But what use does the new Bluetooth 5.2 (Bluetooth Low Energy Audio) from January 6, 2020 have?
What could the previous Bluetooth versions in hearing aids achieve?
- Bluetooth Classic is only available in very few hearing aids because actually it does not make sense. Although it can transmit audio, it consumes a lot of energy, battery-wise, and has a high latency (time between the spoken and heard word) and is therefore not able to lip-sync.
- Bluetooth Low Energy has no audio transmission, so it is only used in Hearing aids for remote control.
- Bluetooth Low Energy with Apple extension (“made for iPhone”) can transmit audio, but only with newer Apple devices, all other smartphones, notebooks and tablets need an additional device, subject to additional charge. There may also be problems with the latency here.
In all three versions, the hearing aid must be registered on the transmitter (the smartphone) i.e. the hearing aid must be individually paired with the transmitter. Before Bluetooth 5.0 only one audio pairing per transmitter was available. From Bluetooth 5.0 on a maximum of two audio receivers could be paired at the same time (e.g. a Bluetooth speaker and a hearing aid), not more.
These are the main reasons why Bluetooth up to version 5.1 is not suitable for a public hearing system
- no audio or only with a special additional device
- high latency
- only two participants maximum
What’s new with Bluetooth Low Energy Audio?
- Bluetooth Low Energy Audio 5.2 is now able to transmit audio, like previously the Bluetooth Classic. Bluetooth Low Energy Audio 5.2 got a brand new CODEC (“LC3”) that shrinks the audio data, as with MP3, so that parts of the language are not transmitted. This reduces the latency to around 5ms. It will only be clear towards the end of 2020 how exactly this will work.
- Bluetooth Low Energy Audio 5.2 now offers a “streaming” solution. In addition, each audio data packet comes with a period of validity. If it cannot be sent during this period (e.g. due to overloading of the Bluetooth chip or network, or not processed by the hearing aid)
it will just be left out. This results in dropouts, crackles and wrong sound in the hearing aid speakers.
- Bluetooth Low Energy Audio 5.2 now also has multi-streaming. One transmitter can have multiple audio streams sent simultaneously i.e. in a conference hall or cinema for translations e.g. German and English. The hearing aid can also subscribe to multiple streams e.g. a soccer game broadcast in a pub and the announcements of the host or an alarm system.
- In addition to the normal pairing between the Bluetooth transmitter and the hearing aid, there is now also the so-called Broadcasting, i.e. a kind of radio. The hearing aid no longer has to be registered or paired with the transmitter but just ‘listens’. There are different types:
- completely free listening
- listening with approval (= passcode). Since Bluetooth radio goes through walls, too, this prevents someone from listening in on a park bench outside the venue.
- With Bluetooth Low Energy Audio 5.2, the hearing aid can automatically connect to a nearby hearing station (e.g. an exhibit in a museum). Additional aids or devices are not required. Although, the hearing aid must be switched to the correct mode beforehand.
So far only the basic plan (core specification) has been adopted, more than 20 necessary detailed features are expected to come later in the year. The first chipsets are expected to be available in a year.
However, all of these new functions are not mandatory for a Bluetooth chip to be recognised as version 5.2, manufacturers are also allowed to install only parts of the standard. That means, even if a new notebook has a Bluetooth 5.2 chip installed, it is far from being said that this PC is suitable for use as a public hearing system. What functions in real hardware, in firmware (programs on the chip), what is in the driver, in the operating system or buried in the application software is not clearly recognizable. Bluetooth Low Energy Audio will also not be available on Android below version 10, so an upgrade to a new device is mandatory for those with older models.
We could not find any information on Apple, although Windows 10 will receive an update at some point. Probably the new chips will be at first installed in the expensive smartphones / tablets / PCs and only afterwards with several years delay on the affordable mid-range devices.
Compatibility with previous devices:
All expensive hearing aids “made for iPhone” will not work with Bluetooth Low Energy Audio, unless a hearing aid manufacturer would develop a Bluetooth Low Energy Audio accessory “made-for-iPhone” and a corresponding app that controls the device. Bluetooth Classic devices could not pair either. It cannot be assumed that hearing aid manufacturers will develop new software for previous Bluetooth hearing aids, create a new driver and replace hardware parts. For each “made for iPhone” hearing aid there already exists an adaptor for Bluetooth Classic. Now theoretically it could be possible, that a third-party manufacturer develops an additional adaptor translating Bluetooth Low Energy Audio to Bluetooth Classic. And these two devices have to be coupled. However, if that should be the case there would be a long latency period between the sound being generated and it being heard, e.g. in a thriller film a victim would fall over before the gun shot would be heard.
But what options will be available hearing aid users that currently use a telecoil ? Currently devices are available for a few Euros which receive Bluetooth Version 4.2 and output on a headphone jack to allow all wired headphones to receive Bluetooth audio. A hearing aid user can use the same device to drive a neck loop. Given that such a device will be required for the much larger headphone market, it is likely that a “Bluetooth 5.2 receiver” will be readily available.
With a Bluetooth Low Energy Audio hearing system, the hearing aid must be paired to the desired audio stream
to receive it. The one to four buttons currently used on hearing systems almost certainly won’t be adequate, especially with content requiring approval; the passcode can hardly be entered on the hearing aid manually. Therefore, it is very likely that a smartphone will always be necessary to control hearing aid technology using this standard. Difficulties arise ensuring all those people who experience hearing loss have a current smartphone. That again takes time, for example even Bluetooth 5.0, launched in December 2016, is not even present in all current early 2020 smartphones.
“Coupling” to public hearing systems
Anyone who has ever tried to pair their Bluetooth speaker with their smartphone knows that this is not always easy. A hearing aid with Bluetooth 5.2 standard has to connect with a Bluetooth hearing system transmitter in a church, the parish hall or in public spaces. That this connection will most likely not be done on the hearing aid itself makes things more problematic and complicated, not easier. Presumably these hearing aids will come with an app. Even ignoring the considerable data protection problems for the moment, the app would communicate with the existing hearing system transmitter and you have to make a choice as to which of the available streams you want to hear. Nobody wants to watch Casablanca, just to hear Star Wars audio from the next room because of a wrong connection or the Spanish language channel instead of the native one. We are interested to see how this will be resolved. So far nothing has been decided yet!
“Coupling” to the induction loop, on the other hand, means that I only place my hearing aid on the telecoil program via a switch. This is one of the 3-6 typical functions of the hearing aid. Mostly it is a button on the hearing aid that is pressed to move from one program to another. Some, more expensive, hearing aids also have an app to enable the mode to be changed via a smartphone.
Every now and then during our consultations we are asked, whether elderly people, in particular, are able to cope with changing their hearing aids to the telecoil program. As a rule they are able, but if they are not, they will definitely not be able to use Bluetooth!
We all hope that one day there will be better and cheaper public hearing system technology that can replace induction. If this should be Bluetooth Low Energy Audio it will still take many years to get there and it will be much, much longer before induction can be replaced completely with a clear conscience. Whether Bluetooth Low Energy Audio is the future will depend on its suitability. 2.4GHz technology is already considered overloaded today. Without change, this problem will only increase further in the future, leading to gaps in the transmission by Bluetooth Low Energy Audio, in transmission aborts or becomes incomprehensible. This would make Bluetooth Low Energy Audio certainly not an appropriate alternative for induction loops.
In the meantime Bluetooth LE-ASHA is available for Android 10. It works similar to Bluetooth Low Energy Apple, but is not compatible with it, neither it is with the other versions. Bluetooth Low Energy ASHA is not intended for public hearing systems. Nevertheless, this makes a total of five (!) different, incompatible Bluetooth Systems for hearing aids to choose from. We will see which system(s) will prevail. Until then Induction loops are the only universally compatible systems.